← Back to player profile
Tilly vs Silent Jeff
Shared game history, mirrored head-to-head record, and full pod context.
Tilly Record
10-8-2
Perspective: Tilly
Silent Jeff Record
2-16-2
Perspective: Silent Jeff
Shared Games
20
Latest Meeting
Jan 31, 2026
First Meeting
Jul 1, 2025
Tilly Commander Stats
| Commander | Games | W-L-D |
|---|---|---|
| Rowan, Scion of War | 17 | 10-7-0 |
| Unknown Commander | 3 | 0-1-2 |
Silent Jeff Commander Stats
| Commander | Games | W-L-D |
|---|---|---|
| Unknown Commander | 20 | 2-16-2 |
Chronological Game History
Sorted newest first. Expand a game to see the full pod and winner highlight.
CriticalEDH February 2026 LeagueDrawJan 31, 2026Round 1Table 494Tilly: Seat 4, Unknown CommanderSilent Jeff: Seat 3, Unknown Commander
CriticalEDH February 2026 League
Draw
Jan 31, 2026Round 1Table 494Tilly: Seat 4, Unknown CommanderSilent Jeff: Seat 3, Unknown Commander
| Seat | Player | Commander | Result |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Matt (Bunnikn1ght) | Unknown Commander | DRAW |
| 2 | Logan Moeller | Unknown Commander | DRAW |
| 3 | Silent Jeff | Unknown Commander | DRAW |
| 4 | Tilly | Unknown Commander | DRAW |
CriticalEDH February 2026 LeagueMatt Hayes wonJan 31, 2026Round 1Table 741Tilly: Seat 4, Unknown CommanderSilent Jeff: Seat 3, Unknown Commander
CriticalEDH February 2026 League
Matt Hayes won
Jan 31, 2026Round 1Table 741Tilly: Seat 4, Unknown CommanderSilent Jeff: Seat 3, Unknown Commander
| Seat | Player | Commander | Result |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Noah Barrios | Unknown Commander | LOSS |
| 2 | Matt Hayes | Unknown Commander | WINNER |
| 3 | Silent Jeff | Unknown Commander | LOSS |
| 4 | Tilly | Unknown Commander | LOSS |
CriticalEDH February 2026 LeagueDrawJan 31, 2026Round 1Table 743Tilly: Seat 2, Unknown CommanderSilent Jeff: Seat 3, Unknown Commander
CriticalEDH February 2026 League
Draw
Jan 31, 2026Round 1Table 743Tilly: Seat 2, Unknown CommanderSilent Jeff: Seat 3, Unknown Commander
| Seat | Player | Commander | Result |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Multiscuf [ISO] | Unknown Commander | DRAW |
| 2 | Tilly | Unknown Commander | DRAW |
| 3 | Silent Jeff | Unknown Commander | DRAW |
| 4 | Rocky | Unknown Commander | DRAW |
CriticalEDH August 2025 LeagueTilly wonJul 31, 2025Round 1Table 174Tilly: Seat 4, Rowan, Scion of WarSilent Jeff: Seat 1, Unknown Commander
CriticalEDH August 2025 League
Tilly won
Jul 31, 2025Round 1Table 174Tilly: Seat 4, Rowan, Scion of WarSilent Jeff: Seat 1, Unknown Commander
| Seat | Player | Commander | Result |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Silent Jeff | Unknown Commander | LOSS |
| 2 | Andrew Jumper | Unknown Commander | LOSS |
| 4 | Tilly | Rowan, Scion of War | WINNER |
CriticalEDH July 2025 LeagueTilly wonJul 1, 2025Round 1Table 140Tilly: Seat 2, Rowan, Scion of WarSilent Jeff: Seat 3, Unknown Commander
CriticalEDH July 2025 League
Tilly won
Jul 1, 2025Round 1Table 140Tilly: Seat 2, Rowan, Scion of WarSilent Jeff: Seat 3, Unknown Commander
| Seat | Player | Commander | Result |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | [abcEDH]Footee | Unknown Commander | LOSS |
| 2 | Tilly | Rowan, Scion of War | WINNER |
| 3 | Silent Jeff | Unknown Commander | LOSS |
| 4 | Dexter Idzikowski | Rograkh, Son of Rohgahh / Silas Renn, Seeker Adept | LOSS |
CriticalEDH July 2025 LeagueSilent Jeff wonJul 1, 2025Round 1Table 142Tilly: Seat 4, Rowan, Scion of WarSilent Jeff: Seat 1, Unknown Commander
CriticalEDH July 2025 League
Silent Jeff won
Jul 1, 2025Round 1Table 142Tilly: Seat 4, Rowan, Scion of WarSilent Jeff: Seat 1, Unknown Commander
| Seat | Player | Commander | Result |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Silent Jeff | Unknown Commander | WINNER |
| 2 | [abcEDH]Footee | Unknown Commander | LOSS |
| 3 | Dexter Idzikowski | Rograkh, Son of Rohgahh / Silas Renn, Seeker Adept | LOSS |
| 4 | Tilly | Rowan, Scion of War | LOSS |
CriticalEDH July 2025 LeagueDexter Idzikowski wonJul 1, 2025Round 1Table 143Tilly: Seat 4, Rowan, Scion of WarSilent Jeff: Seat 2, Unknown Commander
CriticalEDH July 2025 League
Dexter Idzikowski won
Jul 1, 2025Round 1Table 143Tilly: Seat 4, Rowan, Scion of WarSilent Jeff: Seat 2, Unknown Commander
| Seat | Player | Commander | Result |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Dexter Idzikowski | Rograkh, Son of Rohgahh / Silas Renn, Seeker Adept | WINNER |
| 2 | Silent Jeff | Unknown Commander | LOSS |
| 3 | [abcEDH]Footee | Unknown Commander | LOSS |
| 4 | Tilly | Rowan, Scion of War | LOSS |
CriticalEDH July 2025 League[abcEDH]Footee wonJul 1, 2025Round 1Table 145Tilly: Seat 2, Rowan, Scion of WarSilent Jeff: Seat 4, Unknown Commander
CriticalEDH July 2025 League
[abcEDH]Footee won
Jul 1, 2025Round 1Table 145Tilly: Seat 2, Rowan, Scion of WarSilent Jeff: Seat 4, Unknown Commander
| Seat | Player | Commander | Result |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Dexter Idzikowski | Rograkh, Son of Rohgahh / Silas Renn, Seeker Adept | LOSS |
| 2 | Tilly | Rowan, Scion of War | LOSS |
| 3 | [abcEDH]Footee | Unknown Commander | WINNER |
| 4 | Silent Jeff | Unknown Commander | LOSS |
CriticalEDH July 2025 LeagueCorwin Caster [Monolith] wonJul 1, 2025Round 1Table 175Tilly: Seat 4, Rowan, Scion of WarSilent Jeff: Seat 3, Unknown Commander
CriticalEDH July 2025 League
Corwin Caster [Monolith] won
Jul 1, 2025Round 1Table 175Tilly: Seat 4, Rowan, Scion of WarSilent Jeff: Seat 3, Unknown Commander
| Seat | Player | Commander | Result |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | [BFF] Wayne J. Liu | Zirda, the Dawnwaker | LOSS |
| 2 | Corwin Caster [Monolith] | Unknown Commander | WINNER |
| 3 | Silent Jeff | Unknown Commander | LOSS |
| 4 | Tilly | Rowan, Scion of War | LOSS |
CriticalEDH July 2025 LeagueJoseph Hynes wonJul 1, 2025Round 1Table 176Tilly: Seat 4, Rowan, Scion of WarSilent Jeff: Seat 1, Unknown Commander
CriticalEDH July 2025 League
Joseph Hynes won
Jul 1, 2025Round 1Table 176Tilly: Seat 4, Rowan, Scion of WarSilent Jeff: Seat 1, Unknown Commander
| Seat | Player | Commander | Result |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Silent Jeff | Unknown Commander | LOSS |
| 2 | Joseph Hynes | Unknown Commander | WINNER |
| 3 | [BFF] Wayne J. Liu | Zirda, the Dawnwaker | LOSS |
| 4 | Tilly | Rowan, Scion of War | LOSS |
CriticalEDH July 2025 LeagueJase Sanders wonJul 1, 2025Round 1Table 230Tilly: Seat 1, Rowan, Scion of WarSilent Jeff: Seat 4, Unknown Commander
CriticalEDH July 2025 League
Jase Sanders won
Jul 1, 2025Round 1Table 230Tilly: Seat 1, Rowan, Scion of WarSilent Jeff: Seat 4, Unknown Commander
| Seat | Player | Commander | Result |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Tilly | Rowan, Scion of War | LOSS |
| 2 | Crimson [Helios] | Unknown Commander | LOSS |
| 3 | Jase Sanders | Unknown Commander | WINNER |
| 4 | Silent Jeff | Unknown Commander | LOSS |
CriticalEDH July 2025 LeagueSilent Jeff wonJul 1, 2025Round 1Table 281Tilly: Seat 4, Rowan, Scion of WarSilent Jeff: Seat 1, Unknown Commander
CriticalEDH July 2025 League
Silent Jeff won
Jul 1, 2025Round 1Table 281Tilly: Seat 4, Rowan, Scion of WarSilent Jeff: Seat 1, Unknown Commander
| Seat | Player | Commander | Result |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Silent Jeff | Unknown Commander | WINNER |
| 2 | Quincy Eggert | Unknown Commander | LOSS |
| 3 | My Daily Load | Unknown Commander | LOSS |
| 4 | Tilly | Rowan, Scion of War | LOSS |
CriticalEDH July 2025 LeagueTilly wonJul 1, 2025Round 1Table 282Tilly: Seat 3, Rowan, Scion of WarSilent Jeff: Seat 2, Unknown Commander
CriticalEDH July 2025 League
Tilly won
Jul 1, 2025Round 1Table 282Tilly: Seat 3, Rowan, Scion of WarSilent Jeff: Seat 2, Unknown Commander
| Seat | Player | Commander | Result |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Quincy Eggert | Unknown Commander | LOSS |
| 2 | Silent Jeff | Unknown Commander | LOSS |
| 3 | Tilly | Rowan, Scion of War | WINNER |
| 4 | My Daily Load | Unknown Commander | LOSS |
CriticalEDH July 2025 LeagueTilly wonJul 1, 2025Round 1Table 283Tilly: Seat 4, Rowan, Scion of WarSilent Jeff: Seat 2, Unknown Commander
CriticalEDH July 2025 League
Tilly won
Jul 1, 2025Round 1Table 283Tilly: Seat 4, Rowan, Scion of WarSilent Jeff: Seat 2, Unknown Commander
| Seat | Player | Commander | Result |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Tayo Norton | Unknown Commander | LOSS |
| 2 | Silent Jeff | Unknown Commander | LOSS |
| 3 | Sean Wiley | Unknown Commander | LOSS |
| 4 | Tilly | Rowan, Scion of War | WINNER |
CriticalEDH July 2025 LeagueTilly wonJul 1, 2025Round 1Table 375Tilly: Seat 1, Rowan, Scion of WarSilent Jeff: Seat 2, Unknown Commander
CriticalEDH July 2025 League
Tilly won
Jul 1, 2025Round 1Table 375Tilly: Seat 1, Rowan, Scion of WarSilent Jeff: Seat 2, Unknown Commander
| Seat | Player | Commander | Result |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Tilly | Rowan, Scion of War | WINNER |
| 2 | Silent Jeff | Unknown Commander | LOSS |
| 3 | Tayo Norton | Unknown Commander | LOSS |
| 4 | The.Chad.Bod | Unknown Commander | LOSS |
CriticalEDH July 2025 LeagueTilly wonJul 1, 2025Round 1Table 433Tilly: Seat 1, Rowan, Scion of WarSilent Jeff: Seat 4, Unknown Commander
CriticalEDH July 2025 League
Tilly won
Jul 1, 2025Round 1Table 433Tilly: Seat 1, Rowan, Scion of WarSilent Jeff: Seat 4, Unknown Commander
| Seat | Player | Commander | Result |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Tilly | Rowan, Scion of War | WINNER |
| 2 | Zeke Maxwell [Monolith] | Unknown Commander | LOSS |
| 3 | Tayo Norton | Unknown Commander | LOSS |
| 4 | Silent Jeff | Unknown Commander | LOSS |
CriticalEDH July 2025 LeagueTilly wonJul 1, 2025Round 1Table 434Tilly: Seat 3, Rowan, Scion of WarSilent Jeff: Seat 1, Unknown Commander
CriticalEDH July 2025 League
Tilly won
Jul 1, 2025Round 1Table 434Tilly: Seat 3, Rowan, Scion of WarSilent Jeff: Seat 1, Unknown Commander
| Seat | Player | Commander | Result |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Silent Jeff | Unknown Commander | LOSS |
| 2 | Zeke Maxwell [Monolith] | Unknown Commander | LOSS |
| 3 | Tilly | Rowan, Scion of War | WINNER |
| 4 | Tayo Norton | Unknown Commander | LOSS |
CriticalEDH July 2025 LeagueTilly wonJul 1, 2025Round 1Table 453Tilly: Seat 4, Rowan, Scion of WarSilent Jeff: Seat 1, Unknown Commander
CriticalEDH July 2025 League
Tilly won
Jul 1, 2025Round 1Table 453Tilly: Seat 4, Rowan, Scion of WarSilent Jeff: Seat 1, Unknown Commander
| Seat | Player | Commander | Result |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Silent Jeff | Unknown Commander | LOSS |
| 2 | HippieSloth (LelandH) | Unknown Commander | LOSS |
| 3 | Elijah vicino | Unknown Commander | LOSS |
| 4 | Tilly | Rowan, Scion of War | WINNER |
CriticalEDH July 2025 LeagueTilly wonJul 1, 2025Round 1Table 474Tilly: Seat 3, Rowan, Scion of WarSilent Jeff: Seat 2, Unknown Commander
CriticalEDH July 2025 League
Tilly won
Jul 1, 2025Round 1Table 474Tilly: Seat 3, Rowan, Scion of WarSilent Jeff: Seat 2, Unknown Commander
| Seat | Player | Commander | Result |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Alex Walma | Unknown Commander | LOSS |
| 2 | Silent Jeff | Unknown Commander | LOSS |
| 3 | Tilly | Rowan, Scion of War | WINNER |
| 4 | Bobby Greene | Vivi Ornitier | LOSS |
CriticalEDH July 2025 LeagueTilly wonJul 1, 2025Round 1Table 476Tilly: Seat 4, Rowan, Scion of WarSilent Jeff: Seat 2, Unknown Commander
CriticalEDH July 2025 League
Tilly won
Jul 1, 2025Round 1Table 476Tilly: Seat 4, Rowan, Scion of WarSilent Jeff: Seat 2, Unknown Commander
| Seat | Player | Commander | Result |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Sean Wiley | Unknown Commander | LOSS |
| 2 | Silent Jeff | Unknown Commander | LOSS |
| 3 | Breyman Dile | Unknown Commander | LOSS |
| 4 | Tilly | Rowan, Scion of War | WINNER |