Loading player profile…
Loading commander matchups…
Loading achievements…
Data provided by TopDeck.gg
← Back to player profile

Nicholas Roy vs Andy Buttons(chubby)

Shared game history, mirrored head-to-head record, and full pod context.

Nicholas Roy profileAndy Buttons(chubby) profile
Nicholas Roy Record
0-12-2
Perspective: Nicholas Roy
Andy Buttons(chubby) Record
2-10-2
Perspective: Andy Buttons(chubby)
Shared Games
14
Latest Meeting
Jan 31, 2026
First Meeting
Aug 31, 2025
Nicholas Roy Commander Stats
CommanderGamesW-L-D
Unknown Commander140-12-2
Andy Buttons(chubby) Commander Stats
CommanderGamesW-L-D
Unknown Commander142-10-2
Chronological Game History

Sorted newest first. Expand a game to see the full pod and winner highlight.

CriticalEDH February 2026 League
Helixsnake35 won
Jan 31, 2026Round 1Table 1451Nicholas Roy : Seat 2, Unknown CommanderAndy Buttons(chubby) : Seat 4, Unknown Commander
SeatPlayerCommanderResult
1Helixsnake35Unknown CommanderWINNER
2
Nicholas Roy
Unknown Commander
LOSS
3Gavin BerkeyUnknown CommanderLOSS
4Andy Buttons(chubby) Unknown CommanderLOSS
CriticalEDH November 2025 League
JJ//raGemaGe_MTG won
Oct 31, 2025Round 1Table 1458Nicholas Roy : Seat 2, Unknown CommanderAndy Buttons(chubby) : Seat 4, Unknown Commander
SeatPlayerCommanderResult
1Jerry RowlandUnknown CommanderLOSS
2Nicholas Roy Unknown CommanderLOSS
3JJ//raGemaGe_MTGUnknown CommanderWINNER
4Andy Buttons(chubby) Unknown CommanderLOSS
CriticalEDH November 2025 League
Andy Buttons(chubby) won
Oct 31, 2025Round 1Table 1795Nicholas Roy : Seat 2, Unknown CommanderAndy Buttons(chubby) : Seat 3, Unknown Commander
SeatPlayerCommanderResult
1TillyUnknown CommanderLOSS
2Nicholas Roy Unknown CommanderLOSS
3Andy Buttons(chubby) Unknown CommanderWINNER
4Matt ArciuoloUnknown CommanderLOSS
CriticalEDH November 2025 League
Bradley Hart won
Oct 31, 2025Round 1Table 1271Nicholas Roy : Seat 3, Unknown CommanderAndy Buttons(chubby) : Seat 1, Unknown Commander
SeatPlayerCommanderResult
1Andy Buttons(chubby) Unknown CommanderLOSS
2Bradley HartUnknown CommanderWINNER
3Nicholas Roy Unknown CommanderLOSS
4Connor GuinnessUnknown CommanderLOSS
CriticalEDH November 2025 League
Max Safran won
Oct 31, 2025Round 1Table 1260Nicholas Roy : Seat 2, Unknown CommanderAndy Buttons(chubby) : Seat 4, Unknown Commander
SeatPlayerCommanderResult
1Max SafranUnknown CommanderWINNER
2Nicholas Roy Unknown CommanderLOSS
3James DaniellKrark, the Thumbless / Tymna the WeaverLOSS
4Andy Buttons(chubby) Unknown CommanderLOSS
CriticalEDH November 2025 League
Draw
Oct 31, 2025Round 1Table 1278Nicholas Roy : Seat 2, Unknown CommanderAndy Buttons(chubby) : Seat 4, Unknown Commander
SeatPlayerCommanderResult
1[LPW] DameGPTUnknown CommanderDRAW
2Nicholas Roy Unknown CommanderDRAW
3BiscuitUnknown CommanderDRAW
4Andy Buttons(chubby) Unknown CommanderDRAW
CriticalEDH October 2025 League
Smalls [Monolith] won
Sep 30, 2025Round 1Table 1772Nicholas Roy : Seat 4, Unknown CommanderAndy Buttons(chubby) : Seat 3, Unknown Commander
SeatPlayerCommanderResult
1Smalls [Monolith]Unknown CommanderWINNER
2Josh [SOCC]Unknown CommanderLOSS
3Andy Buttons(chubby) Unknown CommanderLOSS
4Nicholas Roy Unknown CommanderLOSS
CriticalEDH October 2025 League
Dexter Idzikowski won
Sep 30, 2025Round 1Table 293Nicholas Roy : Seat 2, Unknown CommanderAndy Buttons(chubby) : Seat 1, Unknown Commander
SeatPlayerCommanderResult
1Andy Buttons(chubby) Unknown CommanderLOSS
2Nicholas Roy Unknown CommanderLOSS
3Dexter IdzikowskiRograkh, Son of Rohgahh / Silas Renn, Seeker AdeptWINNER
4Jase Sanders Unknown CommanderLOSS
CriticalEDH October 2025 League
Jase Sanders won
Sep 30, 2025Round 1Table 297Nicholas Roy : Seat 4, Unknown CommanderAndy Buttons(chubby) : Seat 2, Unknown Commander
SeatPlayerCommanderResult
1Jase Sanders Unknown CommanderWINNER
2Andy Buttons(chubby) Unknown CommanderLOSS
3jadyn stewart- cantin Unknown CommanderLOSS
4Nicholas Roy Unknown CommanderLOSS
CriticalEDH October 2025 League
Jase Sanders won
Sep 30, 2025Round 1Table 299Nicholas Roy : Seat 3, Unknown CommanderAndy Buttons(chubby) : Seat 1, Unknown Commander
SeatPlayerCommanderResult
1Andy Buttons(chubby) Unknown CommanderLOSS
2jadyn stewart- cantin Unknown CommanderLOSS
3Nicholas Roy Unknown CommanderLOSS
4Jase Sanders Unknown CommanderWINNER
CriticalEDH October 2025 League
Christian Mukai won
Sep 30, 2025Round 1Table 407Nicholas Roy : Seat 1, Unknown CommanderAndy Buttons(chubby) : Seat 2, Unknown Commander
SeatPlayerCommanderResult
1Nicholas Roy Unknown CommanderLOSS
2Andy Buttons(chubby) Unknown CommanderLOSS
3Christian MukaiUnknown CommanderWINNER
4Rourke MoranUnknown CommanderLOSS
CriticalEDH October 2025 League
Draw
Sep 30, 2025Round 1Table 1836Nicholas Roy : Seat 4, Unknown CommanderAndy Buttons(chubby) : Seat 2, Unknown Commander
SeatPlayerCommanderResult
1Last SeatUnknown CommanderDRAW
2Andy Buttons(chubby) Unknown CommanderDRAW
3Max C (RND)Unknown CommanderDRAW
4Nicholas Roy Unknown CommanderDRAW
CriticalEDH October 2025 League
Andy Buttons(chubby) won
Sep 30, 2025Round 1Table 398Nicholas Roy : Seat 3, Unknown CommanderAndy Buttons(chubby) : Seat 1, Unknown Commander
SeatPlayerCommanderResult
1Andy Buttons(chubby) Unknown CommanderWINNER
2Rourke MoranUnknown CommanderLOSS
3Nicholas Roy Unknown CommanderLOSS
4Rodrigo I.Unknown CommanderLOSS
CriticalEDH September 2025 League
Tilly won
Aug 31, 2025Round 1Table 1726Nicholas Roy : Seat 3, Unknown CommanderAndy Buttons(chubby) : Seat 2, Unknown Commander
SeatPlayerCommanderResult
1TillyUnknown CommanderWINNER
2Andy Buttons(chubby) Unknown CommanderLOSS
3Nicholas Roy Unknown CommanderLOSS
4Sean BarmapovUnknown CommanderLOSS