← Back to player profile
Jonathan Gibbons vs Tad Gibson
Shared game history, mirrored head-to-head record, and full pod context.
Jonathan Gibbons Record
3-16-2
Perspective: Jonathan Gibbons
Tad Gibson Record
9-10-2
Perspective: Tad Gibson
Shared Games
21
Latest Meeting
Feb 20, 2026
First Meeting
Feb 19, 2023
Jonathan Gibbons Commander Stats
| Commander | Games | W-L-D |
|---|---|---|
| Unknown Commander | 20 | 3-15-2 |
| Meren of Clan Nel Toth | 1 | 0-1-0 |
Tad Gibson Commander Stats
| Commander | Games | W-L-D |
|---|---|---|
| Unknown Commander | 19 | 8-10-1 |
| Thalia and The Gitrog Monster | 1 | 1-0-0 |
| Rograkh, Son of Rohgahh / Silas Renn, Seeker Adept | 1 | 0-0-1 |
Chronological Game History
Sorted newest first. Expand a game to see the full pod and winner highlight.
cEDH League Season 3: Week 5DrawFeb 20, 2026Round 2Table 1NEW YORKJonathan Gibbons: Seat 3, Unknown CommanderTad Gibson: Seat 2, Unknown Commander
cEDH League Season 3: Week 5
Draw
Feb 20, 2026Round 2Table 1NEW YORKJonathan Gibbons: Seat 3, Unknown CommanderTad Gibson: Seat 2, Unknown Commander
| Seat | Player | Commander | Result |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Dio | Unknown Commander | DRAW |
| 2 | Tad Gibson | Unknown Commander | DRAW |
| 3 | Jonathan Gibbons | Unknown Commander | DRAW |
| 4 | SOCKMONSTER | Unknown Commander | DRAW |
cEDH League Season 3: Week 2Ethan Duffy wonJan 30, 2026Round 1Table 1NEW YORKJonathan Gibbons: Seat 3, Unknown CommanderTad Gibson: Seat 2, Unknown Commander
cEDH League Season 3: Week 2
Ethan Duffy won
Jan 30, 2026Round 1Table 1NEW YORKJonathan Gibbons: Seat 3, Unknown CommanderTad Gibson: Seat 2, Unknown Commander
| Seat | Player | Commander | Result |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Josh E Ely | Unknown Commander | LOSS |
| 2 | Tad Gibson | Unknown Commander | LOSS |
| 3 | Jonathan Gibbons | Unknown Commander | LOSS |
| 4 | Ethan Duffy | Unknown Commander | WINNER |
cEDH League Season 3: Week 1Tad Gibson wonJan 23, 2026Round 1Table 2NEW YORKJonathan Gibbons: Seat 3, Unknown CommanderTad Gibson: Seat 1, Unknown Commander
cEDH League Season 3: Week 1
Tad Gibson won
Jan 23, 2026Round 1Table 2NEW YORKJonathan Gibbons: Seat 3, Unknown CommanderTad Gibson: Seat 1, Unknown Commander
| Seat | Player | Commander | Result |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Tad Gibson | Unknown Commander | WINNER |
| 2 | Aaron | Unknown Commander | LOSS |
| 3 | Jonathan Gibbons | Unknown Commander | LOSS |
| 4 | SOCKMONSTER | Unknown Commander | LOSS |
Bufftown Bullies cEDH League S1:W10ScoopPhase wonAug 29, 2025Round 1Table 1NEW YORKJonathan Gibbons: Seat 2, Unknown CommanderTad Gibson: Seat 3, Unknown Commander
Bufftown Bullies cEDH League S1:W10
ScoopPhase won
Aug 29, 2025Round 1Table 1NEW YORKJonathan Gibbons: Seat 2, Unknown CommanderTad Gibson: Seat 3, Unknown Commander
| Seat | Player | Commander | Result |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Michael Pierce (Emmdot) | Unknown Commander | LOSS |
| 2 | Jonathan Gibbons | Unknown Commander | LOSS |
| 3 | Tad Gibson | Unknown Commander | LOSS |
| 4 | ScoopPhase | Unknown Commander | WINNER |
Bufftown Bullies cEDH League S1:W9Tad Gibson wonAug 22, 2025Round 2Table 4NEW YORKJonathan Gibbons: Seat 3, Unknown CommanderTad Gibson: Seat 1, Unknown Commander
Bufftown Bullies cEDH League S1:W9
Tad Gibson won
Aug 22, 2025Round 2Table 4NEW YORKJonathan Gibbons: Seat 3, Unknown CommanderTad Gibson: Seat 1, Unknown Commander
| Seat | Player | Commander | Result |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Tad Gibson | Unknown Commander | WINNER |
| 2 | Dio | Unknown Commander | LOSS |
| 3 | Jonathan Gibbons | Unknown Commander | LOSS |
| 4 | Jake Nowak | Unknown Commander | LOSS |
Bufftown Bullies cEDH League S1:W4Thaddeus Reichert wonJul 11, 2025Round 2Table 1NEW YORKJonathan Gibbons: Seat 4, Unknown CommanderTad Gibson: Seat 2, Unknown Commander
Bufftown Bullies cEDH League S1:W4
Thaddeus Reichert won
Jul 11, 2025Round 2Table 1NEW YORKJonathan Gibbons: Seat 4, Unknown CommanderTad Gibson: Seat 2, Unknown Commander
| Seat | Player | Commander | Result |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Thaddeus Reichert | Unknown Commander | WINNER |
| 2 | Tad Gibson | Unknown Commander | LOSS |
| 3 | Brandon Barlow | Unknown Commander | LOSS |
| 4 | Jonathan Gibbons | Unknown Commander | LOSS |
cEDH Weekly at Mana BarTad Gibson wonMay 16, 2025Round 2Table 3NEW YORKJonathan Gibbons: Seat 1, Unknown CommanderTad Gibson: Seat 2, Unknown Commander
cEDH Weekly at Mana Bar
Tad Gibson won
May 16, 2025Round 2Table 3NEW YORKJonathan Gibbons: Seat 1, Unknown CommanderTad Gibson: Seat 2, Unknown Commander
| Seat | Player | Commander | Result |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Jonathan Gibbons | Unknown Commander | LOSS |
| 2 | Tad Gibson | Unknown Commander | WINNER |
| 3 | Patrick Smith JR | Unknown Commander | LOSS |
| 4 | Josh E Ely | Unknown Commander | LOSS |
Friday FNM cEDHTad Gibson wonMar 14, 2025Round 2Table 1NEW YORKJonathan Gibbons: Seat 1, Unknown CommanderTad Gibson: Seat 3, Unknown Commander
Friday FNM cEDH
Tad Gibson won
Mar 14, 2025Round 2Table 1NEW YORKJonathan Gibbons: Seat 1, Unknown CommanderTad Gibson: Seat 3, Unknown Commander
| Seat | Player | Commander | Result |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Jonathan Gibbons | Unknown Commander | LOSS |
| 2 | Logan Caruso | Unknown Commander | LOSS |
| 3 | Tad Gibson | Unknown Commander | WINNER |
| 4 | ScoopPhase | Unknown Commander | LOSS |
Mana Bar Friday NightJonathan Gibbons wonJan 3, 2025Round 1Table 1Jonathan Gibbons: Seat 1, Unknown CommanderTad Gibson: Seat 3, Unknown Commander
Mana Bar Friday Night
Jonathan Gibbons won
Jan 3, 2025Round 1Table 1Jonathan Gibbons: Seat 1, Unknown CommanderTad Gibson: Seat 3, Unknown Commander
| Seat | Player | Commander | Result |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Jonathan Gibbons | Unknown Commander | WINNER |
| 2 | Ethan Duffy | Unknown Commander | LOSS |
| 3 | Tad Gibson | Unknown Commander | LOSS |
| 4 | Joe Mac | Unknown Commander | LOSS |
Bufftown Bullies Weekly 9/6johnathan wonSep 6, 2024Round 3Table 2NEW YORKJonathan Gibbons: Seat 3, Unknown CommanderTad Gibson: Seat 2, Unknown Commander
Bufftown Bullies Weekly 9/6
johnathan won
Sep 6, 2024Round 3Table 2NEW YORKJonathan Gibbons: Seat 3, Unknown CommanderTad Gibson: Seat 2, Unknown Commander
| Seat | Player | Commander | Result |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Ethan Duffy | Unknown Commander | LOSS |
| 2 | Tad Gibson | Unknown Commander | LOSS |
| 3 | Jonathan Gibbons | Unknown Commander | LOSS |
| 4 | johnathan | Unknown Commander | WINNER |
Bufftown Bullies Present: Win a Volcanic Island (Summer 2024)DrawJul 6, 2024Round 5Table 2NEW YORKJonathan Gibbons: Seat 2, Unknown CommanderTad Gibson: Seat 3, Rograkh, Son of Rohgahh / Silas Renn, Seeker Adept
Bufftown Bullies Present: Win a Volcanic Island (Summer 2024)
Draw
Jul 6, 2024Round 5Table 2NEW YORKJonathan Gibbons: Seat 2, Unknown CommanderTad Gibson: Seat 3, Rograkh, Son of Rohgahh / Silas Renn, Seeker Adept
| Seat | Player | Commander | Result |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Thomas McGinley | Tymna the Weaver / Kraum, Ludevic's Opus | DRAW |
| 2 | Jonathan Gibbons | Unknown Commander | DRAW |
| 3 | Tad Gibson | Rograkh, Son of Rohgahh / Silas Renn, Seeker Adept | DRAW |
| 4 | Dio | Sisay, Weatherlight Captain | DRAW |
Bufftown Bullies Charity $50 EDH TournamentTad Gibson wonMay 11, 2024Top 16Table 3NEW YORKJonathan Gibbons: Seat 2, Meren of Clan Nel TothTad Gibson: Seat 3, Thalia and The Gitrog Monster
Bufftown Bullies Charity $50 EDH Tournament
Tad Gibson won
May 11, 2024Top 16Table 3NEW YORKJonathan Gibbons: Seat 2, Meren of Clan Nel TothTad Gibson: Seat 3, Thalia and The Gitrog Monster
| Seat | Player | Commander | Result |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Gunnar Wuher | Stella Lee, Wild Card | LOSS |
| 2 | Jonathan Gibbons | Meren of Clan Nel Toth | LOSS |
| 3 | Tad Gibson | Thalia and The Gitrog Monster | WINNER |
| 4 | Tyler Williams | Stangg, Echo Warrior | LOSS |
Weekly cEDH 12/15Jonathan Gibbons wonDec 14, 2023Round 1Table 1Jonathan Gibbons: Seat 4, Unknown CommanderTad Gibson: Seat 2, Unknown Commander
Weekly cEDH 12/15
Jonathan Gibbons won
Dec 14, 2023Round 1Table 1Jonathan Gibbons: Seat 4, Unknown CommanderTad Gibson: Seat 2, Unknown Commander
| Seat | Player | Commander | Result |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | ScoopPhase | Unknown Commander | LOSS |
| 2 | Tad Gibson | Unknown Commander | LOSS |
| 3 | johnathan | Unknown Commander | LOSS |
| 4 | Jonathan Gibbons | Unknown Commander | WINNER |
Weekly cEDH 12/15Tad Gibson wonDec 14, 2023FinalsTable 1Jonathan Gibbons: Seat 1, Unknown CommanderTad Gibson: Seat 4, Unknown Commander
Weekly cEDH 12/15
Tad Gibson won
Dec 14, 2023FinalsTable 1Jonathan Gibbons: Seat 1, Unknown CommanderTad Gibson: Seat 4, Unknown Commander
| Seat | Player | Commander | Result |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Jonathan Gibbons | Unknown Commander | LOSS |
| 2 | Aaron | Unknown Commander | LOSS |
| 3 | Thaddeus Reichert | Unknown Commander | LOSS |
| 4 | Tad Gibson | Unknown Commander | WINNER |
CEDH FNMTad Gibson wonDec 7, 2023Round 2Table 1Jonathan Gibbons: Seat 2, Unknown CommanderTad Gibson: Seat 1, Unknown Commander
CEDH FNM
Tad Gibson won
Dec 7, 2023Round 2Table 1Jonathan Gibbons: Seat 2, Unknown CommanderTad Gibson: Seat 1, Unknown Commander
| Seat | Player | Commander | Result |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Tad Gibson | Unknown Commander | WINNER |
| 2 | Jonathan Gibbons | Unknown Commander | LOSS |
| 3 | Brandon Barlow | Unknown Commander | LOSS |
| 4 | johnathan | Unknown Commander | LOSS |
Bufftown Bullies X The Mana Bar: Win a Gaea’s Cradle Tad Gibson wonDec 2, 2023Round 1Table 3NEW YORKJonathan Gibbons: Seat 4, Unknown CommanderTad Gibson: Seat 1, Unknown Commander
Bufftown Bullies X The Mana Bar: Win a Gaea’s Cradle
Tad Gibson won
Dec 2, 2023Round 1Table 3NEW YORKJonathan Gibbons: Seat 4, Unknown CommanderTad Gibson: Seat 1, Unknown Commander
| Seat | Player | Commander | Result |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Tad Gibson | Unknown Commander | WINNER |
| 2 | Brian Knowles | Unknown Commander | LOSS |
| 3 | Reid Esplin | Unknown Commander | LOSS |
| 4 | Jonathan Gibbons | Unknown Commander | LOSS |
Bufftown Bullies Summer BashJay wonJul 28, 2023Round 4Table 3NEW YORKJonathan Gibbons: Seat 1, Unknown CommanderTad Gibson: Seat 4, Unknown Commander
Bufftown Bullies Summer Bash
Jay won
Jul 28, 2023Round 4Table 3NEW YORKJonathan Gibbons: Seat 1, Unknown CommanderTad Gibson: Seat 4, Unknown Commander
| Seat | Player | Commander | Result |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Jonathan Gibbons | Unknown Commander | LOSS |
| 2 | Jay | Unknown Commander | WINNER |
| 3 | Hunter Beaulieu | Unknown Commander | LOSS |
| 4 | Tad Gibson | Unknown Commander | LOSS |
Bufftown Bullies Summer BashJonathan Gibbons wonJul 28, 2023SemifinalsTable 1NEW YORKJonathan Gibbons: Seat 4, Unknown CommanderTad Gibson: Seat 3, Unknown Commander
Bufftown Bullies Summer Bash
Jonathan Gibbons won
Jul 28, 2023SemifinalsTable 1NEW YORKJonathan Gibbons: Seat 4, Unknown CommanderTad Gibson: Seat 3, Unknown Commander
| Seat | Player | Commander | Result |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Aaron | Unknown Commander | LOSS |
| 2 | Chester Bond | Unknown Commander | LOSS |
| 3 | Tad Gibson | Unknown Commander | LOSS |
| 4 | Jonathan Gibbons | Unknown Commander | WINNER |
Bufftown Bullies $50 EDH Deck Charity Event Tad Gibson wonMay 26, 2023Round 1Table 7NEW YORKJonathan Gibbons: Seat 4, Unknown CommanderTad Gibson: Seat 1, Unknown Commander
Bufftown Bullies $50 EDH Deck Charity Event
Tad Gibson won
May 26, 2023Round 1Table 7NEW YORKJonathan Gibbons: Seat 4, Unknown CommanderTad Gibson: Seat 1, Unknown Commander
| Seat | Player | Commander | Result |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Tad Gibson | Unknown Commander | WINNER |
| 2 | Michael caswell | Unknown Commander | LOSS |
| 3 | Eric English | Unknown Commander | LOSS |
| 4 | Jonathan Gibbons | Unknown Commander | LOSS |
Bufftown Bullies $50 EDH Deck Charity Event Ethan Duffy wonMay 26, 2023SemifinalsTable 1NEW YORKJonathan Gibbons: Seat 2, Unknown CommanderTad Gibson: Seat 1, Unknown Commander
Bufftown Bullies $50 EDH Deck Charity Event
Ethan Duffy won
May 26, 2023SemifinalsTable 1NEW YORKJonathan Gibbons: Seat 2, Unknown CommanderTad Gibson: Seat 1, Unknown Commander
| Seat | Player | Commander | Result |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Tad Gibson | Unknown Commander | LOSS |
| 2 | Jonathan Gibbons | Unknown Commander | LOSS |
| 3 | Ethan Duffy | Unknown Commander | WINNER |
| 4 | Steven Johnstone | Unknown Commander | LOSS |
Battle for the BadlandsReid Esplin wonFeb 19, 2023Round 2Table 1NEW YORKJonathan Gibbons: Seat 1, Unknown CommanderTad Gibson: Seat 4, Unknown Commander
Battle for the Badlands
Reid Esplin won
Feb 19, 2023Round 2Table 1NEW YORKJonathan Gibbons: Seat 1, Unknown CommanderTad Gibson: Seat 4, Unknown Commander
| Seat | Player | Commander | Result |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Jonathan Gibbons | Unknown Commander | LOSS |
| 2 | Reid Esplin | Unknown Commander | WINNER |
| 4 | Tad Gibson | Unknown Commander | LOSS |