← Back to player profile

Polyphemus’ Eyepatch // CriticalEDH vs Joshua Libhart

Shared game history, mirrored head-to-head record, and full pod context.

Polyphemus’ Eyepatch // CriticalEDH profile Joshua Libhart profile

Polyphemus’ Eyepatch // CriticalEDH Record

4-7-2

Perspective: Polyphemus’ Eyepatch // CriticalEDH

Joshua Libhart Record

3-8-2

Perspective: Joshua Libhart

Shared Games

13

Latest Meeting

Jan 24, 2026

First Meeting

Nov 23, 2024

Polyphemus’ Eyepatch // CriticalEDH Commander Stats

Commander	Games	W-L-D
Unknown Commander	11	4-6-1
Tymna the Weaver / Kraum, Ludevic's Opus	1	0-1-0
Vivi Ornitier	1	0-0-1

Joshua Libhart Commander Stats

Commander	Games	W-L-D
Unknown Commander	12	3-7-2

Chronological Game History

Sorted newest first. Expand a game to see the full pod and winner highlight.

LEVEL SEVEN'S WEEKLY CEDH EVENT

Joshua Libhart won

Jan 24, 2026Round 1Table 2Polyphemus’ Eyepatch // CriticalEDH: Seat 3, Unknown CommanderJoshua Libhart: Seat 4, Unknown Commander

Seat	Player	Commander	Result
1	Connor Slack	Unknown Commander	LOSS
2

LEVEL SEVEN'S WEEKLY CEDH EVENT

Draw

Jan 24, 2026Round 2Table 4Polyphemus’ Eyepatch // CriticalEDH: Seat 3, Unknown CommanderJoshua Libhart: Seat 1, Unknown Commander

Seat	Player	Commander	Result
1	Joshua Libhart	Unknown Commander	DRAW
2	Titus Timely Talker (EBAM)	Unknown Commander	DRAW
3	Polyphemus’ Eyepatch // CriticalEDH	Unknown Commander	DRAW
4	Abrham Montes	Unknown Commander	DRAW

LEVEL SEVEN'S WEEKLY CEDH EVENT

Joshua Libhart won

Jan 17, 2026Round 4Table 6Polyphemus’ Eyepatch // CriticalEDH: Seat 2, Unknown CommanderJoshua Libhart: Seat 1, Unknown Commander

Seat	Player	Commander	Result
1	Joshua Libhart	Unknown Commander	WINNER
2	Polyphemus’ Eyepatch // CriticalEDH	Unknown Commander	LOSS
3	Stephen Gray	Unknown Commander	LOSS
4	Marshall Smith	Unknown Commander	LOSS

LEVEL SEVEN'S WEEKLY CEDH EVENT

Polyphemus’ Eyepatch // CriticalEDH won

Dec 27, 2025Round 3Table 1Polyphemus’ Eyepatch // CriticalEDH: Seat 2, Unknown CommanderJoshua Libhart: Seat 4, Unknown Commander

Seat	Player	Commander	Result
1	[CRASH] Joshua Braverman	Unknown Commander	LOSS
2	Polyphemus’ Eyepatch // CriticalEDH	Unknown Commander	WINNER
3	Cade Arvin	Unknown Commander	LOSS
4	Joshua Libhart	Unknown Commander	LOSS

LEVEL SEVEN'S WEEKLY CEDH EVENT

Draw

Jul 5, 2025Round 1Table 2Polyphemus’ Eyepatch // CriticalEDH: Seat 2, Vivi OrnitierJoshua Libhart: Seat 3, Unknown Commander

Seat	Player	Commander	Result
1	Callan Peterson	Unknown Commander	DRAW
2	Polyphemus’ Eyepatch // CriticalEDH	Vivi Ornitier	DRAW
3	Joshua Libhart	Unknown Commander	DRAW
4	Titus Timely Talker (EBAM)	Unknown Commander	DRAW

LEVEL SEVEN'S WEEKLY CEDH EVENT

Nathaniel McClure won

Jun 7, 2025Round 2Table 8Polyphemus’ Eyepatch // CriticalEDH: Seat 2, Unknown CommanderJoshua Libhart: Seat 3, Unknown Commander

Seat	Player	Commander	Result
1	Luca Voeller	Unknown Commander	LOSS
2	Polyphemus’ Eyepatch // CriticalEDH	Unknown Commander	LOSS
3	Joshua Libhart	Unknown Commander	LOSS
4	Nathaniel McClure	Unknown Commander	WINNER

LEVEL SEVEN'S WEEKLY CEDH EVENT

Polyphemus’ Eyepatch // CriticalEDH won

May 17, 2025Round 4Table 4Polyphemus’ Eyepatch // CriticalEDH: Seat 2, Unknown CommanderJoshua Libhart: Seat 1, Unknown Commander

Seat	Player	Commander	Result
1	Joshua Libhart	Unknown Commander	LOSS
2	Polyphemus’ Eyepatch // CriticalEDH	Unknown Commander	WINNER
3	Evan Bodek	Unknown Commander	LOSS
4	Tyler Lindblad	Unknown Commander	LOSS

LEVEL SEVEN'S WEEKLY CEDH EVENT

Tyler Lindblad won

Apr 5, 2025Round 1Table 2COLORADOPolyphemus’ Eyepatch // CriticalEDH: Seat 1, Unknown CommanderJoshua Libhart: Seat 4, Unknown Commander

Seat	Player	Commander	Result
1	Polyphemus’ Eyepatch // CriticalEDH	Unknown Commander	LOSS
2	Tyler Lindblad	Unknown Commander	WINNER
3	Nicholas Kenney	Unknown Commander	LOSS
4	Joshua Libhart	Unknown Commander	LOSS

LEVEL SEVEN'S WEEKLY CEDH EVENT

haynn tang won

Mar 8, 2025Round 3Table 3COLORADOPolyphemus’ Eyepatch // CriticalEDH: Seat 3, Unknown CommanderJoshua Libhart: Seat 2, Unknown Commander

Seat	Player	Commander	Result
1	Elior Bilow	Unknown Commander	LOSS
2	Joshua Libhart	Unknown Commander	LOSS
3	Polyphemus’ Eyepatch // CriticalEDH	Unknown Commander	LOSS
4	haynn tang	Unknown Commander	WINNER

Commander Tournament

Polyphemus’ Eyepatch // CriticalEDH won

Feb 8, 2025Round 4Table 3COLORADOPolyphemus’ Eyepatch // CriticalEDH: Seat 1, Unknown CommanderJoshua Libhart: Seat 2, Unknown Commander

Seat	Player	Commander	Result
1	Polyphemus’ Eyepatch // CriticalEDH	Unknown Commander	WINNER
2	Joshua Libhart	Unknown Commander	LOSS
3	Stephen Gray	Unknown Commander	LOSS
4	Emily Doan	Unknown Commander	LOSS

Enchanted Grounds $1k

haynn tang won

Jan 25, 2025Top 4Table 1COLORADOPolyphemus’ Eyepatch // CriticalEDH: Seat 1, Tymna the Weaver / Kraum, Ludevic's OpusJoshua Libhart: Seat 3, Sisay, Weatherlight Captain

Seat	Player	Commander	Result
1	Polyphemus’ Eyepatch // CriticalEDH	Tymna the Weaver / Kraum, Ludevic's Opus	LOSS
2	Jonah Murray	Kinnan, Bonder Prodigy	LOSS
3	Joshua Libhart	Sisay, Weatherlight Captain	LOSS
4	haynn tang	Shorikai, Genesis Engine	WINNER

Commader Event

Joshua Libhart won

Jan 4, 2025Round 2Table 3COLORADOPolyphemus’ Eyepatch // CriticalEDH: Seat 2, Unknown CommanderJoshua Libhart: Seat 3, Unknown Commander

Seat	Player	Commander	Result
1	nicholas klecker	Unknown Commander	LOSS
2	Polyphemus’ Eyepatch // CriticalEDH	Unknown Commander	LOSS
3	Joshua Libhart	Unknown Commander	WINNER
4	Timothy J Moss	Unknown Commander	LOSS

Commander Tournament

Polyphemus’ Eyepatch // CriticalEDH won

Nov 23, 2024Round 3Table 2COLORADOPolyphemus’ Eyepatch // CriticalEDH: Seat 1, Unknown CommanderJoshua Libhart: Seat 4, Unknown Commander

Seat	Player	Commander	Result
1	Polyphemus’ Eyepatch // CriticalEDH	Unknown Commander	WINNER
2	Jordan Callister	Unknown Commander	LOSS
3	Bryant W	Rowan, Scion of War	LOSS
4	Joshua Libhart	Unknown Commander	LOSS