← Back to player profile

Shaka vs Duncan Gilchrist

Shared game history, mirrored head-to-head record, and full pod context.

Shaka profile Duncan Gilchrist profile

Shaka Record

11-11-14

Perspective: Shaka

Duncan Gilchrist Record

10-12-14

Perspective: Duncan Gilchrist

Shared Games

36

Latest Meeting

Jan 31, 2026

First Meeting

Nov 16, 2024

Shaka Commander Stats

Commander	Games	W-L-D
Unknown Commander	22	7-8-7
Sisay, Weatherlight Captain	10	1-2-7
Krark, the Thumbless / Silas Renn, Seeker Adept	4	3-1-0

Duncan Gilchrist Commander Stats

Commander	Games	W-L-D
Unknown Commander	30	9-8-13
Krark, the Thumbless / Silas Renn, Seeker Adept	2	1-0-1
Tymna the Weaver / Tana, the Bloodsower	2	0-2-0
Sisay, Weatherlight Captain	1	0-1-0
Tayam, Luminous Enigma	1	0-1-0

Chronological Game History

Sorted newest first. Expand a game to see the full pod and winner highlight.

CriticalEDH February 2026 League

Draw

Jan 31, 2026Round 1Table 1879Shaka: Seat 1, Unknown CommanderDuncan Gilchrist: Seat 4, Unknown Commander

Seat	Player	Commander	Result
1	Shaka	Unknown Commander	DRAW
2	Alex W	Unknown Commander	DRAW
3	Algenus Kenrith	Unknown Commander	DRAW
4	Duncan Gilchrist	Unknown Commander	DRAW

CriticalEDH February 2026 League

Draw

Jan 31, 2026Round 1Table 1138Shaka: Seat 1, Unknown CommanderDuncan Gilchrist: Seat 2, Unknown Commander

Seat	Player	Commander	Result
1	Shaka	Unknown Commander	DRAW
2	Duncan Gilchrist	Unknown Commander	DRAW
3	Mark segaric	Unknown Commander	DRAW
4	Nick Paoli	Unknown Commander	DRAW

CriticalEDH February 2026 League

Draw

Jan 31, 2026Round 1Table 1139Shaka: Seat 3, Unknown CommanderDuncan Gilchrist: Seat 2, Unknown Commander

Seat	Player	Commander	Result
1	Mark segaric	Unknown Commander	DRAW
2	Duncan Gilchrist	Unknown Commander	DRAW
3	Shaka	Unknown Commander	DRAW
4	Nick Paoli	Unknown Commander	DRAW

CriticalEDH February 2026 League

Draw

Jan 31, 2026Round 1Table 2519Shaka: Seat 4, Unknown CommanderDuncan Gilchrist: Seat 3, Unknown Commander

Seat	Player	Commander	Result
1	kai levett	Unknown Commander	DRAW
2	CptMoralSupport	Unknown Commander	DRAW
3	Duncan Gilchrist	Unknown Commander	DRAW
4	Shaka	Unknown Commander	DRAW

CriticalEDH February 2026 League

Duncan Gilchrist won

Jan 31, 2026Round 1Table 445Shaka: Seat 4, Unknown CommanderDuncan Gilchrist: Seat 1, Unknown Commander

Seat	Player	Commander	Result
1	Duncan Gilchrist	Unknown Commander	WINNER
2	Alec🐊 Salameh	Unknown Commander	LOSS
3	Kamden K	Unknown Commander	LOSS
4	Shaka	Unknown Commander	LOSS

CriticalEDH February 2026 League

Shaka won

Jan 31, 2026Round 1Table 1039Shaka: Seat 3, Unknown CommanderDuncan Gilchrist: Seat 2, Unknown Commander

Seat	Player	Commander	Result
1	Georgie	Unknown Commander	LOSS
2	Duncan Gilchrist	Unknown Commander	LOSS
3	Shaka	Unknown Commander	WINNER
4	Mark segaric	Unknown Commander	LOSS

CriticalEDH February 2026 League

Shaka won

Jan 31, 2026Round 1Table 2521Shaka: Seat 4, Unknown CommanderDuncan Gilchrist: Seat 2, Unknown Commander

Seat	Player	Commander	Result
1	CptMoralSupport	Unknown Commander	LOSS
2	Duncan Gilchrist	Unknown Commander	LOSS
3	kai levett	Unknown Commander	LOSS
4	Shaka	Unknown Commander	WINNER

CriticalEDH February 2026 League

Shaka won

Jan 31, 2026Round 1Table 1709Shaka: Seat 1, Unknown CommanderDuncan Gilchrist: Seat 4, Unknown Commander

Seat	Player	Commander	Result
1	Shaka	Unknown Commander	WINNER
2	Corey J.M. Williams	Unknown Commander	LOSS
3	Johannes P	Unknown Commander	LOSS
4	Duncan Gilchrist	Unknown Commander	LOSS

CriticalEDH February 2026 League

Duncan Gilchrist won

Jan 31, 2026Round 1Table 1036Shaka: Seat 4, Unknown CommanderDuncan Gilchrist: Seat 1, Unknown Commander

Seat	Player	Commander	Result
1	Duncan Gilchrist	Unknown Commander	WINNER
2	Georgie	Unknown Commander	LOSS
3	Mark segaric	Unknown Commander	LOSS
4	Shaka	Unknown Commander	LOSS

CriticalEDH February 2026 League

Shaka won

Jan 31, 2026Round 1Table 1131Shaka: Seat 2, Unknown CommanderDuncan Gilchrist: Seat 3, Unknown Commander

Seat	Player	Commander	Result
1	Mark segaric	Unknown Commander	LOSS
2	Shaka	Unknown Commander	WINNER
3	Duncan Gilchrist	Unknown Commander	LOSS
4	Yandere_simper	Unknown Commander	LOSS

CriticalEDH January 2026 League

Shaka won

Jan 3, 2026Round 1Table 244Shaka: Seat 3, Unknown CommanderDuncan Gilchrist: Seat 4, Unknown Commander

Seat	Player	Commander	Result
1	Aaron Shaffer	Unknown Commander	LOSS
2	[JITM] Drake Turner	Unknown Commander	LOSS
3	Shaka	Unknown Commander	WINNER
4	Duncan Gilchrist	Unknown Commander	LOSS

CriticalEDH January 2026 League

Duncan Gilchrist won

Jan 3, 2026Round 1Table 957Shaka: Seat 2, Unknown CommanderDuncan Gilchrist: Seat 1, Unknown Commander

Seat	Player	Commander	Result
1	Duncan Gilchrist	Unknown Commander	WINNER
2	Shaka	Unknown Commander	LOSS
3	Jason Lew [KTTY]	Unknown Commander	LOSS
4	Matt Arciuolo	Unknown Commander	LOSS

CriticalEDH January 2026 League

Draw

Jan 3, 2026Round 1Table 716Shaka: Seat 2, Unknown CommanderDuncan Gilchrist: Seat 3, Unknown Commander

Seat	Player	Commander	Result
1	Michael Zheng	Unknown Commander	DRAW
2	Shaka	Unknown Commander	DRAW
3	Duncan Gilchrist	Unknown Commander	DRAW
4	Seth Amarasinghe	Unknown Commander	DRAW

CriticalEDH January 2026 League

[JITM] Drake Turner won

Jan 3, 2026Round 1Table 247Shaka: Seat 2, Unknown CommanderDuncan Gilchrist: Seat 1, Unknown Commander

Seat	Player	Commander	Result
1	Duncan Gilchrist	Unknown Commander	LOSS
2	Shaka	Unknown Commander	LOSS
3	[JITM] Drake Turner	Unknown Commander	WINNER
4	Aaron Shaffer	Unknown Commander	LOSS

CriticalEDH January 2026 League

Duncan Gilchrist won

Jan 3, 2026Round 1Table 614Shaka: Seat 3, Unknown CommanderDuncan Gilchrist: Seat 1, Unknown Commander

Seat	Player	Commander	Result
1	Duncan Gilchrist	Unknown Commander	WINNER
2	Jonathan Ortiz	Unknown Commander	LOSS
3	Shaka	Unknown Commander	LOSS
4	Jupi	Unknown Commander	LOSS

CriticalEDH January 2026 League

Draw

Jan 3, 2026Round 1Table 1312Shaka: Seat 3, Unknown CommanderDuncan Gilchrist: Seat 2, Unknown Commander

Seat	Player	Commander	Result
1	Austen Louden ::BC::	Unknown Commander	DRAW
2	Duncan Gilchrist	Unknown Commander	DRAW
3	Shaka	Unknown Commander	DRAW
4	Tony Dao	Unknown Commander	DRAW

CriticalEDH January 2026 League

Shaka won

Jan 3, 2026Round 1Table 1310Shaka: Seat 1, Unknown CommanderDuncan Gilchrist: Seat 2, Unknown Commander

Seat	Player	Commander	Result
1	Shaka	Unknown Commander	WINNER
2	Duncan Gilchrist	Unknown Commander	LOSS
3	Austen Louden ::BC::	Unknown Commander	LOSS
4	Tony Dao	Unknown Commander	LOSS

CriticalEDH December 2025 League

Draw

Nov 30, 2025Round 1Table 151Shaka: Seat 3, Sisay, Weatherlight CaptainDuncan Gilchrist: Seat 4, Unknown Commander

Seat	Player	Commander	Result
1	Calvin Tyson	Unknown Commander	DRAW
2	Corey J.M. Williams	Unknown Commander	DRAW
3	Shaka	Sisay, Weatherlight Captain	DRAW
4	Duncan Gilchrist	Unknown Commander	DRAW

CriticalEDH December 2025 League

Duncan Gilchrist won

Nov 30, 2025Round 1Table 384Shaka: Seat 4, Sisay, Weatherlight CaptainDuncan Gilchrist: Seat 1, Unknown Commander

Seat	Player	Commander	Result
1	Duncan Gilchrist	Unknown Commander	WINNER
2	Brandon "Mr. Dusk" Arizmendi [Prowess]	Unknown Commander	LOSS
3	Lennon	Unknown Commander	LOSS
4	Shaka	Sisay, Weatherlight Captain	LOSS

CriticalEDH December 2025 League

Draw

Nov 30, 2025Round 1Table 260Shaka: Seat 4, Sisay, Weatherlight CaptainDuncan Gilchrist: Seat 3, Unknown Commander

Seat	Player	Commander	Result
1	Greedy	Unknown Commander	DRAW
2	Corey J.M. Williams	Unknown Commander	DRAW
3	Duncan Gilchrist	Unknown Commander	DRAW
4	Shaka	Sisay, Weatherlight Captain	DRAW

Dragon Shield #ECL December 2025

Draw

Nov 30, 2025Round 1Table 342Shaka: Seat 4, Sisay, Weatherlight CaptainDuncan Gilchrist: Seat 1, Unknown Commander

Seat	Player	Commander	Result
1	Duncan Gilchrist	Unknown Commander	DRAW
2	Jaime Faria	Unknown Commander	DRAW
3	Lorenzonator	Unknown Commander	DRAW
4	Shaka	Sisay, Weatherlight Captain	DRAW

Dragon Shield #ECL December 2025

Draw

Nov 30, 2025Round 1Table 163Shaka: Seat 3, Sisay, Weatherlight CaptainDuncan Gilchrist: Seat 4, Unknown Commander

Seat	Player	Commander	Result
1	Johannes P	Unknown Commander	DRAW
2	Dinis	Chatterfang, Squirrel General	DRAW
3	Shaka	Sisay, Weatherlight Captain	DRAW
4	Duncan Gilchrist	Unknown Commander	DRAW

CriticalEDH November 2025 League

Draw

Oct 31, 2025Round 1Table 78Shaka: Seat 4, Sisay, Weatherlight CaptainDuncan Gilchrist: Seat 1, Unknown Commander

Seat	Player	Commander	Result
1	Duncan Gilchrist	Unknown Commander	DRAW
2	Dexter Idzikowski	Rograkh, Son of Rohgahh / Silas Renn, Seeker Adept	DRAW
3	Kipper	Unknown Commander	DRAW
4	Shaka	Sisay, Weatherlight Captain	DRAW

CriticalEDH November 2025 League

Draw

Oct 31, 2025Round 1Table 74Shaka: Seat 3, Sisay, Weatherlight CaptainDuncan Gilchrist: Seat 4, Unknown Commander

Seat	Player	Commander	Result
1	Dexter Idzikowski	Rograkh, Son of Rohgahh / Silas Renn, Seeker Adept	DRAW
2	Kipper	Unknown Commander	DRAW
3	Shaka	Sisay, Weatherlight Captain	DRAW
4	Duncan Gilchrist	Unknown Commander	DRAW

CriticalEDH November 2025 League

Duncan Gilchrist won

Oct 31, 2025Round 1Table 2050Shaka: Seat 2, Sisay, Weatherlight CaptainDuncan Gilchrist: Seat 1, Unknown Commander

Seat	Player	Commander	Result
1	Duncan Gilchrist	Unknown Commander	WINNER
2	Shaka	Sisay, Weatherlight Captain	LOSS
3	Droopymccool	Unknown Commander	LOSS
4	CptMoralSupport	Unknown Commander	LOSS

CriticalEDH November 2025 League

Draw

Oct 31, 2025Round 1Table 2054Shaka: Seat 3, Sisay, Weatherlight CaptainDuncan Gilchrist: Seat 1, Unknown Commander

Seat	Player	Commander	Result
1	Duncan Gilchrist	Unknown Commander	DRAW
2	Droopymccool	Unknown Commander	DRAW
3	Shaka	Sisay, Weatherlight Captain	DRAW
4	CptMoralSupport	Unknown Commander	DRAW

TM Circuit Act 6: Crisis

Shaka won

Sep 6, 2025Top 4Table 1Shaka: Seat 3, Sisay, Weatherlight CaptainDuncan Gilchrist: Seat 4, Sisay, Weatherlight Captain

Seat	Player	Commander	Result
1	EnderMorph	Tymna the Weaver / Kraum, Ludevic's Opus	LOSS
2	thecroce \| brian	Dihada, Binder of Wills	LOSS
3	Shaka	Sisay, Weatherlight Captain	WINNER
4	Duncan Gilchrist	Sisay, Weatherlight Captain	LOSS

CriticalEDH September 2025 League

Duncan Gilchrist won

Aug 31, 2025Round 1Table 142Shaka: Seat 3, Unknown CommanderDuncan Gilchrist: Seat 1, Unknown Commander

Seat	Player	Commander	Result
1	Duncan Gilchrist	Unknown Commander	WINNER
2	Mark segaric	Unknown Commander	LOSS
3	Shaka	Unknown Commander	LOSS
4	Kenlin	Unknown Commander	LOSS

CriticalEDH September 2025 League

Shaka won

Aug 31, 2025Round 1Table 39Shaka: Seat 1, Unknown CommanderDuncan Gilchrist: Seat 2, Unknown Commander

Seat	Player	Commander	Result
1	Shaka	Unknown Commander	WINNER
2	Duncan Gilchrist	Unknown Commander	LOSS
3	Don Ranns	Unknown Commander	LOSS
4	BR1CKSQUAD	Unknown Commander	LOSS

CriticalEDH September 2025 League

Duncan Gilchrist won

Aug 31, 2025Round 1Table 42Shaka: Seat 2, Unknown CommanderDuncan Gilchrist: Seat 3, Unknown Commander

Seat	Player	Commander	Result
1	CptMoralSupport	Unknown Commander	LOSS
2	Shaka	Unknown Commander	LOSS
3	Duncan Gilchrist	Unknown Commander	WINNER
4	greedy	Unknown Commander	LOSS

CriticalEDH August 2025 League

Duncan Gilchrist won

Jul 31, 2025Round 1Table 192Shaka: Seat 1, Unknown CommanderDuncan Gilchrist: Seat 3, Unknown Commander

Seat	Player	Commander	Result
1	Shaka	Unknown Commander	LOSS
2	[LPW] DameGPT	Unknown Commander	LOSS
3	Duncan Gilchrist	Unknown Commander	WINNER
4	Tanner Bark	Unknown Commander	LOSS

TM Circuit Act 2: Threshold Cutter

Duncan Gilchrist won

Feb 15, 2025Round 5Table 4Shaka: Seat 1, Krark, the Thumbless / Silas Renn, Seeker AdeptDuncan Gilchrist: Seat 4, Krark, the Thumbless / Silas Renn, Seeker Adept

Seat	Player	Commander	Result
1	Shaka	Krark, the Thumbless / Silas Renn, Seeker Adept	LOSS
2	Rafael Vega (Mr Rainbow)	Hashaton, Scarab's Fist	LOSS
3	CptMoralSupport	Unknown Commander	LOSS
4	Duncan Gilchrist	Krark, the Thumbless / Silas Renn, Seeker Adept	WINNER

TOPTIERBANGERS MONEY MONDAYS#26 LAST COMMANDER STANDING

Shaka won

Jan 20, 2025Round 1Table 1Shaka: Seat 3, Krark, the Thumbless / Silas Renn, Seeker AdeptDuncan Gilchrist: Seat 4, Tayam, Luminous Enigma

Seat	Player	Commander	Result
1	jdog [Monolith]	Tymna the Weaver / Thrasios, Triton Hero	LOSS
2	Kai	Rigo, Streetwise Mentor	LOSS
3	Shaka	Krark, the Thumbless / Silas Renn, Seeker Adept	WINNER
4	Duncan Gilchrist	Tayam, Luminous Enigma	LOSS

TM Circuit Act 1: Inciting Incident

Draw

Jan 18, 2025Round 3Table 3Shaka: Seat 2, Unknown CommanderDuncan Gilchrist: Seat 3, Krark, the Thumbless / Silas Renn, Seeker Adept

Seat	Player	Commander	Result
1	Johnny Ellington	Tymna the Weaver / Thrasios, Triton Hero	DRAW
2	Shaka	Unknown Commander	DRAW
3	Duncan Gilchrist	Krark, the Thumbless / Silas Renn, Seeker Adept	DRAW
4	Zach Gilbaugh	Francisco, Fowl Marauder / Thrasios, Triton Hero	DRAW

The Second Tough Mulligans 500

Shaka won

Nov 16, 2024Round 1Table 5Shaka: Seat 2, Krark, the Thumbless / Silas Renn, Seeker AdeptDuncan Gilchrist: Seat 4, Tymna the Weaver / Tana, the Bloodsower

Seat	Player	Commander	Result
1	Colton McCreary	Krark, the Thumbless / Sakashima of a Thousand Faces	LOSS
2	Shaka	Krark, the Thumbless / Silas Renn, Seeker Adept	WINNER
3	Aleks B	Kinnan, Bonder Prodigy	LOSS
4	Duncan Gilchrist	Tymna the Weaver / Tana, the Bloodsower	LOSS

The Second Tough Mulligans 500

Shaka won

Nov 16, 2024Top 16Table 4Shaka: Seat 3, Krark, the Thumbless / Silas Renn, Seeker AdeptDuncan Gilchrist: Seat 1, Tymna the Weaver / Tana, the Bloodsower

Seat	Player	Commander	Result
1	Duncan Gilchrist	Tymna the Weaver / Tana, the Bloodsower	LOSS
2	Hungry Guitar Student	Kinnan, Bonder Prodigy	LOSS
3	Shaka	Krark, the Thumbless / Silas Renn, Seeker Adept	WINNER
4	Tré	Animar, Soul of Elements	LOSS