← Back to player profile

Andrew brennan vs Matt Hayes

Shared game history, mirrored head-to-head record, and full pod context.

Andrew brennan profile Matt Hayes profile

Game filter

Shared W-L-D stats can be limited to Elo-worthy events with 30+ players; Elo rankings are unchanged.

Show 30+ player games only

Andrew brennan Record

1-23-10

Perspective: Andrew brennan

Matt Hayes Record

17-7-10

Perspective: Matt Hayes

Shared Games

34

Latest Meeting

Jun 6, 2026

First Meeting

Jul 31, 2025

Andrew brennan Commander Stats

Commander	Games	W-L-D
Unknown Commander	34	1-23-10

Matt Hayes Commander Stats

Commander	Games	W-L-D
Unknown Commander	23	11-5-7
Tymna the Weaver / Kraum, Ludevic's Opus	11	6-2-3

Chronological Game History

Sorted newest first. Expand a game to see the full pod and winner highlight.

MATT HAYES ASKED ME TO MAKE A TOURNAMENT BECAUSE HE IS BACK IN MASSACHUSETTS SO WE DECIDED TO BECAUSE WHY THE HELL NOT? CEDH TOURNAMENT

Matt Hayes won

Jun 6, 2026Round 2Table 2MAAndrew brennan: Seat 4, Unknown CommanderMatt Hayes: Seat 2, Tymna the Weaver / Kraum, Ludevic's Opus

Seat	Player	Commander	Result
1	Johnald	Tymna the Weaver / Kraum, Ludevic's Opus

MATT HAYES ASKED ME TO MAKE A TOURNAMENT BECAUSE HE IS BACK IN MASSACHUSETTS SO WE DECIDED TO BECAUSE WHY THE HELL NOT? CEDH TOURNAMENT

Matt Hayes won

Jun 6, 2026Top 4Table 1MAAndrew brennan: Seat 4, Unknown CommanderMatt Hayes: Seat 2, Tymna the Weaver / Kraum, Ludevic's Opus

Seat	Player	Commander	Result
1	Marcus Armstrong	Thrasios, Triton Hero / Yoshimaru, Ever Faithful	LOSS
2	Matt Hayes	Tymna the Weaver / Kraum, Ludevic's Opus	WINNER
3	Clinton Fleming	Winota, Joiner of Forces	LOSS
4	Andrew brennan	Unknown Commander	LOSS

CriticalEDH February 2026 League

Draw

Feb 1, 2026Round 1Table 124Andrew brennan: Seat 1, Unknown CommanderMatt Hayes: Seat 3, Unknown Commander

Seat	Player	Commander	Result
1	Andrew brennan	Unknown Commander	DRAW
2	Ben Larson	Unknown Commander	DRAW
3	Matt Hayes	Unknown Commander	DRAW
4	Ben Munroe	Unknown Commander	DRAW

CriticalEDH February 2026 League

Matt Hayes won

Feb 1, 2026Round 1Table 234Andrew brennan: Seat 1, Unknown CommanderMatt Hayes: Seat 4, Unknown Commander

Seat	Player	Commander	Result
1	Andrew brennan	Unknown Commander	LOSS
2	crusty	Unknown Commander	LOSS
3	Harmjan de Vries	Unknown Commander	LOSS
4	Matt Hayes	Unknown Commander	WINNER

CriticalEDH February 2026 League

Draw

Feb 1, 2026Round 1Table 1152Andrew brennan: Seat 2, Unknown CommanderMatt Hayes: Seat 3, Unknown Commander

Seat	Player	Commander	Result
1	Nick Courville	Unknown Commander	DRAW
2	Andrew brennan	Unknown Commander	DRAW
3	Matt Hayes	Unknown Commander	DRAW
4	AdamDaViking	Unknown Commander	DRAW

CriticalEDH February 2026 League

Draw

Feb 1, 2026Round 1Table 1381Andrew brennan: Seat 3, Unknown CommanderMatt Hayes: Seat 1, Unknown Commander

Seat	Player	Commander	Result
1	Matt Hayes	Unknown Commander	DRAW
2	Max C (Uncs)	Unknown Commander	DRAW
3	Andrew brennan	Unknown Commander	DRAW
4	Tyler Keating / SWAT	Unknown Commander	DRAW

CriticalEDH February 2026 League

Matt Hayes won

Feb 1, 2026Round 1Table 1160Andrew brennan: Seat 2, Unknown CommanderMatt Hayes: Seat 3, Unknown Commander

Seat	Player	Commander	Result
1	Andrew Giller	Unknown Commander	LOSS
2	Andrew brennan	Unknown Commander	LOSS
3	Matt Hayes	Unknown Commander	WINNER
4	Nicholas J Gassaway	Unknown Commander	LOSS

CriticalEDH January 2026 League

Matt Hayes won

Jan 4, 2026Round 1Table 798Andrew brennan: Seat 4, Unknown CommanderMatt Hayes: Seat 3, Tymna the Weaver / Kraum, Ludevic's Opus

Seat	Player	Commander	Result
1	TumbleOP	Unknown Commander	LOSS
2	Harmjan de Vries	Unknown Commander	LOSS
3	Matt Hayes	Tymna the Weaver / Kraum, Ludevic's Opus	WINNER
4	Andrew brennan	Unknown Commander	LOSS

CriticalEDH EOY '25 SPRINT LEAGUE

Matt Hayes won

Dec 21, 2025Round 1Table 72Andrew brennan: Seat 1, Unknown CommanderMatt Hayes: Seat 4, Unknown Commander

Seat	Player	Commander	Result
1	Andrew brennan	Unknown Commander	LOSS
2	Nicholas Roy	Unknown Commander	LOSS
3	Max C (Uncs)	Unknown Commander	LOSS
4	Matt Hayes	Unknown Commander	WINNER

CriticalEDH EOY '25 SPRINT LEAGUE

Draw

Dec 21, 2025Round 1Table 74Andrew brennan: Seat 2, Unknown CommanderMatt Hayes: Seat 3, Unknown Commander

Seat	Player	Commander	Result
1	Max C (Uncs)	Unknown Commander	DRAW
2	Andrew brennan	Unknown Commander	DRAW
3	Matt Hayes	Unknown Commander	DRAW
4	Nicholas Roy	Unknown Commander	DRAW

The "Matt Hayes is leaving and hasn't been able to make it to a tournament because of scheduling conflicts" Impromptu CEDH TOURNEY

Matt Hayes won

Oct 11, 2025Top 4Table 1MAAndrew brennan: Seat 4, Unknown CommanderMatt Hayes: Seat 1, Tymna the Weaver / Kraum, Ludevic's Opus

Seat	Player	Commander	Result
1	Matt Hayes	Tymna the Weaver / Kraum, Ludevic's Opus	WINNER
2	Joshua Markiewicz	Ob Nixilis, Captive Kingpin	LOSS
3	Anthony Snyder	Unknown Commander	LOSS
4	Andrew brennan	Unknown Commander	LOSS

CriticalEDH October 2025 League

Sebastian Gwinn won

Oct 1, 2025Round 1Table 1668Andrew brennan: Seat 3, Unknown CommanderMatt Hayes: Seat 4, Tymna the Weaver / Kraum, Ludevic's Opus

Seat	Player	Commander	Result
1	unban griselbrand	Unknown Commander	LOSS
2	Sebastian Gwinn	Unknown Commander	WINNER
3	Andrew brennan	Unknown Commander	LOSS
4	Matt Hayes	Tymna the Weaver / Kraum, Ludevic's Opus	LOSS

CriticalEDH October 2025 League

Matt Hayes won

Oct 1, 2025Round 1Table 973Andrew brennan: Seat 1, Unknown CommanderMatt Hayes: Seat 4, Tymna the Weaver / Kraum, Ludevic's Opus

Seat	Player	Commander	Result
1	Andrew brennan	Unknown Commander	LOSS
2	Taylor With a Y	Unknown Commander	LOSS
3	Alladin Alwi	Unknown Commander	LOSS
4	Matt Hayes	Tymna the Weaver / Kraum, Ludevic's Opus	WINNER

CriticalEDH October 2025 League

Draw

Oct 1, 2025Round 1Table 946Andrew brennan: Seat 1, Unknown CommanderMatt Hayes: Seat 2, Tymna the Weaver / Kraum, Ludevic's Opus

Seat	Player	Commander	Result
1	Andrew brennan	Unknown Commander	DRAW
2	Matt Hayes	Tymna the Weaver / Kraum, Ludevic's Opus	DRAW
3	Alexander	Unknown Commander	DRAW
4	Bomber15 (Nate)	Unknown Commander	DRAW

CriticalEDH October 2025 League

Matt Hayes won

Oct 1, 2025Round 1Table 1665Andrew brennan: Seat 1, Unknown CommanderMatt Hayes: Seat 3, Tymna the Weaver / Kraum, Ludevic's Opus

Seat	Player	Commander	Result
1	Andrew brennan	Unknown Commander	LOSS
2	Sebastian Gwinn	Unknown Commander	LOSS
3	Matt Hayes	Tymna the Weaver / Kraum, Ludevic's Opus	WINNER
4	unban griselbrand	Unknown Commander	LOSS

CriticalEDH October 2025 League

Draw

Oct 1, 2025Round 1Table 1461Andrew brennan: Seat 2, Unknown CommanderMatt Hayes: Seat 3, Tymna the Weaver / Kraum, Ludevic's Opus

Seat	Player	Commander	Result
1	Austen Louden ::BC::	Unknown Commander	DRAW
2	Andrew brennan	Unknown Commander	DRAW
3	Matt Hayes	Tymna the Weaver / Kraum, Ludevic's Opus	DRAW
4	Sebastian Gwinn	Unknown Commander	DRAW

CriticalEDH October 2025 League

Andrew brennan won

Oct 1, 2025Round 1Table 1456Andrew brennan: Seat 2, Unknown CommanderMatt Hayes: Seat 4, Tymna the Weaver / Kraum, Ludevic's Opus

Seat	Player	Commander	Result
1	Austen Louden ::BC::	Unknown Commander	LOSS
2	Andrew brennan	Unknown Commander	WINNER
3	Sebastian Gwinn	Unknown Commander	LOSS
4	Matt Hayes	Tymna the Weaver / Kraum, Ludevic's Opus	LOSS

CriticalEDH October 2025 League

Draw

Oct 1, 2025Round 1Table 1662Andrew brennan: Seat 4, Unknown CommanderMatt Hayes: Seat 3, Tymna the Weaver / Kraum, Ludevic's Opus

Seat	Player	Commander	Result
1	unban griselbrand	Unknown Commander	DRAW
2	Sebastian Gwinn	Unknown Commander	DRAW
3	Matt Hayes	Tymna the Weaver / Kraum, Ludevic's Opus	DRAW
4	Andrew brennan	Unknown Commander	DRAW

CriticalEDH September 2025 League

Matt Hayes won

Aug 31, 2025Round 1Table 595Andrew brennan: Seat 1, Unknown CommanderMatt Hayes: Seat 2, Unknown Commander

Seat	Player	Commander	Result
1	Andrew brennan	Unknown Commander	LOSS
2	Matt Hayes	Unknown Commander	WINNER
3	Thayne Stamberger	Unknown Commander	LOSS
4	Cam "LittleDog" Reid	Unknown Commander	LOSS

CriticalEDH September 2025 League

Matt Hayes won

Aug 31, 2025Round 1Table 812Andrew brennan: Seat 1, Unknown CommanderMatt Hayes: Seat 4, Unknown Commander

Seat	Player	Commander	Result
1	Andrew brennan	Unknown Commander	LOSS
2	Max C (Uncs)	Unknown Commander	LOSS
3	Mike McBurnie	Unknown Commander	LOSS
4	Matt Hayes	Unknown Commander	WINNER

CriticalEDH September 2025 League

Draw

Aug 31, 2025Round 1Table 822Andrew brennan: Seat 1, Unknown CommanderMatt Hayes: Seat 4, Unknown Commander

Seat	Player	Commander	Result
1	Andrew brennan	Unknown Commander	DRAW
2	Max C (Uncs)	Unknown Commander	DRAW
3	Mike McBurnie	Unknown Commander	DRAW
4	Matt Hayes	Unknown Commander	DRAW

CriticalEDH September 2025 League

Matt Hayes won

Aug 31, 2025Round 1Table 831Andrew brennan: Seat 3, Unknown CommanderMatt Hayes: Seat 1, Unknown Commander

Seat	Player	Commander	Result
1	Matt Hayes	Unknown Commander	WINNER
2	Mike McBurnie	Unknown Commander	LOSS
3	Andrew brennan	Unknown Commander	LOSS
4	Max C (Uncs)	Unknown Commander	LOSS

CriticalEDH September 2025 League

Matt Hayes won

Aug 31, 2025Round 1Table 1284Andrew brennan: Seat 4, Unknown CommanderMatt Hayes: Seat 3, Unknown Commander

Seat	Player	Commander	Result
1	Max C (Uncs)	Unknown Commander	LOSS
2	Alladin Alwi	Unknown Commander	LOSS
3	Matt Hayes	Unknown Commander	WINNER
4	Andrew brennan	Unknown Commander	LOSS

CriticalEDH September 2025 League

Max C (Uncs) won

Aug 31, 2025Round 1Table 697Andrew brennan: Seat 1, Unknown CommanderMatt Hayes: Seat 2, Unknown Commander

Seat	Player	Commander	Result
1	Andrew brennan	Unknown Commander	LOSS
2	Matt Hayes	Unknown Commander	LOSS
3	Max C (Uncs)	Unknown Commander	WINNER
4	Jonathan Ferguson	Unknown Commander	LOSS

CriticalEDH September 2025 League

Draw

Aug 31, 2025Round 1Table 1286Andrew brennan: Seat 3, Unknown CommanderMatt Hayes: Seat 4, Unknown Commander

Seat	Player	Commander	Result
1	Alladin Alwi	Unknown Commander	DRAW
2	Max C (Uncs)	Unknown Commander	DRAW
3	Andrew brennan	Unknown Commander	DRAW
4	Matt Hayes	Unknown Commander	DRAW

CriticalEDH September 2025 League

Bomber15 (Nate) won

Aug 31, 2025Round 1Table 616Andrew brennan: Seat 4, Unknown CommanderMatt Hayes: Seat 3, Unknown Commander

Seat	Player	Commander	Result
1	Max C (Uncs)	Unknown Commander	LOSS
2	Bomber15 (Nate)	Unknown Commander	WINNER
3	Matt Hayes	Unknown Commander	LOSS
4	Andrew brennan	Unknown Commander	LOSS

CriticalEDH September 2025 League

Max C (Uncs) won

Aug 31, 2025Round 1Table 1275Andrew brennan: Seat 1, Unknown CommanderMatt Hayes: Seat 2, Unknown Commander

Seat	Player	Commander	Result
1	Andrew brennan	Unknown Commander	LOSS
2	Matt Hayes	Unknown Commander	LOSS
3	Max C (Uncs)	Unknown Commander	WINNER
4	Notorious	Gyruda, Doom of Depths	LOSS

CriticalEDH September 2025 League

Max C (Uncs) won

Aug 31, 2025Round 1Table 621Andrew brennan: Seat 4, Unknown CommanderMatt Hayes: Seat 3, Unknown Commander

Seat	Player	Commander	Result
1	Max C (Uncs)	Unknown Commander	WINNER
2	Bomber15 (Nate)	Unknown Commander	LOSS
3	Matt Hayes	Unknown Commander	LOSS
4	Andrew brennan	Unknown Commander	LOSS

CriticalEDH September 2025 League

Matt Hayes won

Aug 31, 2025Round 1Table 702Andrew brennan: Seat 1, Unknown CommanderMatt Hayes: Seat 4, Unknown Commander

Seat	Player	Commander	Result
1	Andrew brennan	Unknown Commander	LOSS
2	Max C (Uncs)	Unknown Commander	LOSS
3	Jonathan Ferguson	Unknown Commander	LOSS
4	Matt Hayes	Unknown Commander	WINNER

CriticalEDH September 2025 League

Draw

Aug 31, 2025Round 1Table 608Andrew brennan: Seat 1, Unknown CommanderMatt Hayes: Seat 4, Unknown Commander

Seat	Player	Commander	Result
1	Andrew brennan	Unknown Commander	DRAW
2	[JITM] Carson Willis	Unknown Commander	DRAW
3	Luke Lindsay	Unknown Commander	DRAW
4	Matt Hayes	Unknown Commander	DRAW

CriticalEDH August 2025 League

Matt Hayes won

Jul 31, 2025Round 1Table 846Andrew brennan: Seat 1, Unknown CommanderMatt Hayes: Seat 3, Unknown Commander

Seat	Player	Commander	Result
1	Andrew brennan	Unknown Commander	LOSS
2	Tilly	Rowan, Scion of War	LOSS
3	Matt Hayes	Unknown Commander	WINNER
4	Blackbeard	Unknown Commander	LOSS

CriticalEDH August 2025 League

Blackbeard won

Jul 31, 2025Round 1Table 844Andrew brennan: Seat 4, Unknown CommanderMatt Hayes: Seat 2, Unknown Commander

Seat	Player	Commander	Result
1	Blackbeard	Unknown Commander	WINNER
2	Matt Hayes	Unknown Commander	LOSS
3	Tilly	Rowan, Scion of War	LOSS
4	Andrew brennan	Unknown Commander	LOSS

CriticalEDH August 2025 League

Matt Hayes won

Jul 31, 2025Round 1Table 1101Andrew brennan: Seat 3, Unknown CommanderMatt Hayes: Seat 1, Unknown Commander

Seat	Player	Commander	Result
1	Matt Hayes	Unknown Commander	WINNER
2	Max C (Uncs)	Tymna the Weaver / Kraum, Ludevic's Opus	LOSS
3	Andrew brennan	Unknown Commander	LOSS
4	Will Carona	Unknown Commander	LOSS

CriticalEDH August 2025 League

Matt Hayes won

Jul 31, 2025Round 1Table 1220Andrew brennan: Seat 1, Unknown CommanderMatt Hayes: Seat 3, Unknown Commander

Seat	Player	Commander	Result
1	Andrew brennan	Unknown Commander	LOSS
2	ZachIsWeird	Unknown Commander	LOSS
3	Matt Hayes	Unknown Commander	WINNER
4	John B (StrykerCEDH)	Unknown Commander	LOSS