← Back to player profile
GrumpyGarp vs Nate Stidum
Shared game history, mirrored head-to-head record, and full pod context.
GrumpyGarp Record
4-3-2
Perspective: GrumpyGarp
Nate Stidum Record
2-5-2
Perspective: Nate Stidum
Shared Games
9
Latest Meeting
Jan 31, 2026
First Meeting
Sep 30, 2025
GrumpyGarp Commander Stats
| Commander | Games | W-L-D |
|---|---|---|
| Unknown Commander | 9 | 4-3-2 |
Nate Stidum Commander Stats
| Commander | Games | W-L-D |
|---|---|---|
| Unknown Commander | 8 | 2-4-2 |
| Kefka, Court Mage | 1 | 0-1-0 |
Chronological Game History
Sorted newest first. Expand a game to see the full pod and winner highlight.
CriticalEDH February 2026 LeagueDrawJan 31, 2026Round 1Table 2643GrumpyGarp: Seat 2, Unknown CommanderNate Stidum: Seat 1, Unknown Commander
CriticalEDH February 2026 League
Draw
Jan 31, 2026Round 1Table 2643GrumpyGarp: Seat 2, Unknown CommanderNate Stidum: Seat 1, Unknown Commander
| Seat | Player | Commander | Result |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Nate Stidum | Unknown Commander | DRAW |
| 2 | GrumpyGarp | Unknown Commander | DRAW |
| 3 | sprocx | Unknown Commander | DRAW |
| 4 | Droopymccool | Unknown Commander | DRAW |
CriticalEDH February 2026 LeagueGrumpyGarp wonJan 31, 2026Round 1Table 1288GrumpyGarp: Seat 2, Unknown CommanderNate Stidum: Seat 1, Unknown Commander
CriticalEDH February 2026 League
GrumpyGarp won
Jan 31, 2026Round 1Table 1288GrumpyGarp: Seat 2, Unknown CommanderNate Stidum: Seat 1, Unknown Commander
| Seat | Player | Commander | Result |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Nate Stidum | Unknown Commander | LOSS |
| 2 | GrumpyGarp | Unknown Commander | WINNER |
| 3 | Danny Renaud (teddyjunes) | Unknown Commander | LOSS |
| 4 | sprocx | Unknown Commander | LOSS |
CriticalEDH February 2026 LeagueNate Stidum wonJan 31, 2026Round 1Table 1285GrumpyGarp: Seat 3, Unknown CommanderNate Stidum: Seat 1, Unknown Commander
CriticalEDH February 2026 League
Nate Stidum won
Jan 31, 2026Round 1Table 1285GrumpyGarp: Seat 3, Unknown CommanderNate Stidum: Seat 1, Unknown Commander
| Seat | Player | Commander | Result |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Nate Stidum | Unknown Commander | WINNER |
| 2 | Danny Renaud (teddyjunes) | Unknown Commander | LOSS |
| 3 | GrumpyGarp | Unknown Commander | LOSS |
| 4 | sprocx | Unknown Commander | LOSS |
CriticalEDH February 2026 LeagueAlex Lane wonJan 31, 2026Round 1Table 1471GrumpyGarp: Seat 4, Unknown CommanderNate Stidum: Seat 2, Unknown Commander
CriticalEDH February 2026 League
Alex Lane won
Jan 31, 2026Round 1Table 1471GrumpyGarp: Seat 4, Unknown CommanderNate Stidum: Seat 2, Unknown Commander
| Seat | Player | Commander | Result |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Alex Lane | Unknown Commander | WINNER |
| 2 | Nate Stidum | Unknown Commander | LOSS |
| 3 | sprocx | Unknown Commander | LOSS |
| 4 | GrumpyGarp | Unknown Commander | LOSS |
CriticalEDH February 2026 LeagueDrawJan 31, 2026Round 1Table 1466GrumpyGarp: Seat 2, Unknown CommanderNate Stidum: Seat 1, Unknown Commander
CriticalEDH February 2026 League
Draw
Jan 31, 2026Round 1Table 1466GrumpyGarp: Seat 2, Unknown CommanderNate Stidum: Seat 1, Unknown Commander
| Seat | Player | Commander | Result |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Nate Stidum | Unknown Commander | DRAW |
| 2 | GrumpyGarp | Unknown Commander | DRAW |
| 3 | Alex Lane | Unknown Commander | DRAW |
| 4 | sprocx | Unknown Commander | DRAW |
CriticalEDH February 2026 LeagueGrumpyGarp wonJan 31, 2026Round 1Table 690GrumpyGarp: Seat 1, Unknown CommanderNate Stidum: Seat 4, Unknown Commander
CriticalEDH February 2026 League
GrumpyGarp won
Jan 31, 2026Round 1Table 690GrumpyGarp: Seat 1, Unknown CommanderNate Stidum: Seat 4, Unknown Commander
| Seat | Player | Commander | Result |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | GrumpyGarp | Unknown Commander | WINNER |
| 2 | sprocx | Unknown Commander | LOSS |
| 3 | Oliver Davidson | Unknown Commander | LOSS |
| 4 | Nate Stidum | Unknown Commander | LOSS |
CriticalEDH February 2026 LeagueNate Stidum wonJan 31, 2026Round 1Table 1290GrumpyGarp: Seat 4, Unknown CommanderNate Stidum: Seat 2, Unknown Commander
CriticalEDH February 2026 League
Nate Stidum won
Jan 31, 2026Round 1Table 1290GrumpyGarp: Seat 4, Unknown CommanderNate Stidum: Seat 2, Unknown Commander
| Seat | Player | Commander | Result |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Danny Renaud (teddyjunes) | Unknown Commander | LOSS |
| 2 | Nate Stidum | Unknown Commander | WINNER |
| 3 | sprocx | Unknown Commander | LOSS |
| 4 | GrumpyGarp | Unknown Commander | LOSS |
CriticalEDH November 2025 LeagueGrumpyGarp wonOct 31, 2025Round 1Table 1312GrumpyGarp: Seat 1, Unknown CommanderNate Stidum: Seat 2, Unknown Commander
CriticalEDH November 2025 League
GrumpyGarp won
Oct 31, 2025Round 1Table 1312GrumpyGarp: Seat 1, Unknown CommanderNate Stidum: Seat 2, Unknown Commander
| Seat | Player | Commander | Result |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | GrumpyGarp | Unknown Commander | WINNER |
| 2 | Nate Stidum | Unknown Commander | LOSS |
| 3 | Brian S (UncleB) | Unknown Commander | LOSS |
| 4 | Wayne Lawson | Unknown Commander | LOSS |
CriticalEDH October 2025 LeagueGrumpyGarp wonSep 30, 2025Round 1Table 344GrumpyGarp: Seat 1, Unknown CommanderNate Stidum: Seat 4, Kefka, Court Mage
CriticalEDH October 2025 League
GrumpyGarp won
Sep 30, 2025Round 1Table 344GrumpyGarp: Seat 1, Unknown CommanderNate Stidum: Seat 4, Kefka, Court Mage
| Seat | Player | Commander | Result |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | GrumpyGarp | Unknown Commander | WINNER |
| 2 | Light [DC] | Unknown Commander | LOSS |
| 3 | Jeffrey M | Unknown Commander | LOSS |
| 4 | Nate Stidum | Kefka, Court Mage | LOSS |